31 properties · Papamoa Beach, Papamoa

Monticello Key, Papamoa Beach

Monticello Key in Papamoa Beach has 31 properties, valued by the council between $1,020,000 and $2,170,000 with a median of $1,325,000 (Papamoa Beach: $965,000). Most of its homes were built in the 2000s. We estimate its homes at a median $1,390,000. 3 sold in the last twelve months, for a median $1,430,000. The highest sale in 2026 was 43 Monticello Key, at $2,650,000.

$1.32mmedian council valuation
$1.39mour median estimate
$1.43mmedian sale, last 12 months · 3 sales
2000median year built
PapamoaPapamoa Beach ×Monticello Key ×

31 properties on Monticello Key, Papamoa Beach

Highest and lowest on Monticello Key

Highest-valued home39 Monticello Key$2,170,000council valuation · 5 bed · 384 m² floor · 705 m² land
Lowest-valued home3 Monticello Key$1,020,000council valuation · 4 bed · 180 m² floor · 487 m² land
Highest sale in 202643 Monticello Key$2,650,000sold 24 Apr 2026 · 5 bed · 347 m² floor · 669 m² land

Property values on Monticello Key

The council values Monticello Key's 31 rated properties between $1,020,000 and $2,170,000. The middle half sit between about $1,150,000 and $1,825,000; the median is $1,325,000 and the mean $1,464,677.

Lowest: $1.02m$1.02mLowest10%: $1.11m20%: $1.14m20%30%: $1.16m40%: $1.2m40%Median: $1.32m60%: $1.42m60%70%: $1.79m80%: $1.86m80%90%: $1.94mHighest: $2.17m$2.17mHighest
BedroomsHomesMedian council valueSold, last 12 monthsMedian sale
31$1.06m1—
418$1.19m1—
5+12$1.84m1—

Council rating valuations: the council's figure for apportioning rates, not a market appraisal.

Monticello Key compared with Papamoa Beach

Monticello Key's median council value is 37% above Papamoa Beach's.

Monticello KeyPapamoa BeachPapamoa
Median council value$1.32m$965k$945k
Median sale, last 12 months$1.43m$1.01m$975k
Sold in the last 12 months9.7%4.8%4.9%
Time between sales7.0 yrs7.0 yrs6.5 yrs
Median section669 m²550 m²522 m²
Median year built200020002000
Council value per m² of floor$5k$6k$6k

Monticello Key house prices over time

Median sale price by year; 2026 is the year so far. A year with fewer than two sales has no bar.

2016: $530k (3 sales)$530k2017: too few sales to say (1 sale)20172018: $1.16m (3 sales)2019: $954k (6 sales)20192021: $1.4m (3 sales)2022: $1.5m (3 sales)$1.5m20222023: $1.41m (3 sales)2024: $1.27m (2 sales)20242025: $1.29m (2 sales)2026: $1.43m (3 sales, this year so far)$1.43m2026
Sales by year as a table
YearSalesMedian pricePer m² floor
20263$1,430,000$7,448
20252$1,292,500$5,167
20242$1,268,500$5,321
20233$1,405,000$5,109
20223$1,500,000$6,787
20213$1,400,000$6,279
20196$953,600$4,182
20183$1,155,000$5,044
20171$945,000$4,145
20163$530,000$1,577

Recent sales on Monticello Key

The homes on Monticello Key

Monticello Key has 31 houses. Most were built in the 2000s (81%).

2000s: 25 (25 homes)252000s2010s: 5 (5 homes)2010s2020s: 1 (1 home)12020s

How long owners stay on Monticello Key

Homes on Monticello Key that resold in the last five years had been held a median 7.0 years (Papamoa Beach: 7.0 years).

Time between a home's sales, for 14 resales in the last five years. A home not sold since our records begin is not counted, so owners who stay longest are under-represented.

Building and resource consents on Monticello Key

6building consents in the last 5 years
  • 43 Monticello Key1 Jul 2026 · Building consentInstallation of pool fencing
  • 48 Monticello Key1 Nov 2025 · Building consentInstall pool fencing only.
  • 17 Monticello Key1 Sept 2024 · Building consentAlt to dwg, alt to master suite, bdrm three, bathrm, kitchen, dining & lounge areas including structural & bracing elelments
  • 43 Monticello Key1 Apr 2024 · Building consentConstruction of a two-storey three-bdrm dwg with an attached dbl gge.
  • 44 Monticello Key1 Apr 2022 · Building consentInstallation of pool fencing

Sales and valuations as at 11 September 2026, from council and LINZ records. Medians resting on fewer than 3 sales are not shown.

Agents who sold on Monticello Key

The real estate agents credited on Monticello Key sales since 2016, most first. Selling here? These are the agents who have sold your neighbours' homes. A count of sales, not a rating. Every agent who sold in Papamoa Beach.

  1. Evan NorrisRay White Papamoa
    4 sales on Monticello Key · last Aug 2023
  2. Nicholas MeloniYour Property HQ
    2 sales on Monticello Key · last Aug 2026
  3. Charlotte GardnerEves Realty Limited Papamoa
    2 sales on Monticello Key · last Apr 2026
  4. Angela FleetBayleys Mount Maunganui
    2 sales on Monticello Key · last Jan 2023
  5. Darren YoungArizto
    1 sale on Monticello Key · last Sep 2024
  6. Gareth ApplebyRay White Papamoa
    1 sale on Monticello Key · last Sep 2023
  7. Melanie TaylorCollab Realty
    1 sale on Monticello Key · last Nov 2022
  8. Lauren MacRaeEves Realty Limited Papamoa
    1 sale on Monticello Key · last Jun 2018

31 sales on Monticello Key since 2016; 14 of them name an agent we can show, and the counts here are taken from those.

Every address on Monticello Key

31

About property on Monticello Key, Papamoa Beach

Every property in Monticello Key, Papamoa Beach, whether it is for sale or not: homes, sections, farms, lifestyle blocks, shops, offices and industrial land. Each is listed from the council rating roll and Toitū Te Whenua LINZ, with the listing beside it when an agent is marketing it.

Each property has its own page: our estimate of its value beside the council rating valuation, past sale prices, the title and land area, zoning and hazards, building consents, and what it would cost to own.

Listings are published by the agents who market them. Addresses, land details and rating valuations come from Toitū Te Whenua Land Information New Zealand and from the council. No ownership information is published.

Header photo: (c) Elias Freyhof, some rights reserved (CC BY), CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (licence).